1 min read
Football Insider

The Managerial Showdown: Brian Clough vs Jose Mourinho - A Clash of Titans

Unveiling the intriguing hypothetical battle between the legendary Brian Clough and the disruptive force that is Jose Mourinho. Former Nottingham Forest goalkeeper Mark Crossley sheds light on why there'd 'only be one winner' in this clash of European Cup-winning coaches.

The Managerial Showdown: Brian Clough vs Jose Mourinho - A Clash of Titans

Back in the 1970s and 80s, Brian Clough prided himself on upsetting the establishment. In more recent times, Jose Mourinho has taken on the role of managerial disrupter in chief. What would have happened had a couple of European Cup-winning coaches locked horns at the peak of their powers? Former Nottingham Forest goalkeeper Mark Crossley has explained to GOAL why there would “only be one winner”.Clough, who was always unapologetically outspoken, will forever be associated with the ‘Miracle Men’ that delivered back-to-back continental crowns to the City Ground in 1979 and 1980. Alongside Peter Taylor, he turned a provincial second tier outfit into the kings of Europe.English football may never see his like again, as coaches surrender total control at any given club, but Mourinho occupies a similar talent bracket when it comes to mercurial tacticians. He claimed Champions League crowns with Porto and Inter, while overseeing domestic title glory at Chelsea and Real Madrid.Crossley was among those to enjoy the privilege of working under Clough at Forest. Speaking to GOAL while piecing together a Bally Bet All-Stars squad, Crossley said when asked if ‘Old Big ‘Ead’ versus ‘The Special One’ would have been box office - with a fellow former Reds star delivering similar drama for television audiences in 2026: “It would, yeah. But I know there would have been only one winner!“I've seen interviews with top interviewees, Parkinson, and there's Muhammad Ali and all that. There's only ever one winner when Brian Clough's involved. But oh God, it would have made great television.“That's why I love [Roy] Keane, because he's got the traits of him [Clough]. I can watch a game of football on a Sunday afternoon and if it's boring, I can turn it off. But I turn it back on at full time because I want to hear what Keane's saying. And I think that would be the case with Brian Clough.“Brian Clough would not lose in an argument with anybody. He once told us he was going to be Prime Minister and we believed him. I just wish he was around today to be involved in those battles with the managers. But there would only be one winner. We all know that.”Crossley is getting his own taste of management at present, as he is charged with the task of assembling a Bally Bet All-Stars Vets squad that will face a team of Forest legends at the City Ground in May.Asked how he has set about following in Clough’s iconic footsteps, Crossley said: “I've made a few notes and I'm constantly doing it on a daily basis. It's going okay. And the vets can sign up via the club page and they can still do that right up to the 24th of March. The chance to play at the City Ground and a chance for me to pick those players.“But I am going to be leaning also on a few surprises that are playing vets football that I might have to draft into my squad. I once got fined for playing as a ringer for Clough's son’s team. The FA can't fine me for doing that now, in charge of the vets, so I can draft in who I want! So watch this space. People can still sign up and we'll be choosing players at random to play at the City Ground. What a great opportunity.”Add GOAL.com as a preferred source on Google to see more of our reportingCrossley got the chance to grace that venue on countless occasions across his 12 years as a Forest player. He savoured the end of Clough’s historic 18-year tenure, with emotion spilling out across Trentside when a teary farewell was bid in 1993.Asked why modern bosses struggle to enjoy such longevity, Crossley said: “Personally, I think that a manager walks through a door now and there's that much pressure instantly from up above the manager. Go back to like [Arsene] Wenger, [Alex] Ferguson, even Mourinho when he came to Chelsea and your Brian Cloughs. They were called the manager of the football club. They weren't called head coach. There wasn't a head of recruitment. So they ran the club from top to bottom. So they signed the players that they wanted to fit into their team. They picked the youth players that were coming through. Nobody else. They did it. And I believe that that's where the game's completely changed.“Now - I want to say manager - now a head coach is put in charge of a team to coach the team, but someone else signs the players. I really don't get it. And then there becomes confusion where the manager might go: ‘Well, I don't want that player. Yeah, well, you're having him. You do the best with him because we want to then sell him on, whether it's a young one or whatever’. So I don't get it because I don't believe you can get success like that.“I believe managers go into a football club… I say managers again, a head coach, should I say, goes into a football club now and the instant he goes in, he fears for his job because if he loses three or four games on the trot, he's under pressure from up above, from supporters, from whoever it may be. And in today's modern game, it always seems to be the manager's fault. I never hear the players mentioned, whereas back in the day, it was the players that got the stick if the team weren't doing well, not the manager. But now it's, I hear this quote - ‘He's lost the dressing room’. I still don't really know what that means. How do they know when they're not in it?“So I think everything put into one, and maybe I'm being a little bit old school here, but in the 90s, when I thought football was great - great players, bad pitches, you could tackle, you could kick people and pick them up, you could talk to a referee, you could talk to the press, you could talk to your manager, you could go and see your manager and talk about things that were going wrong. I think that's drifted away.“I was just watching a bit of the Overlap the other day and Gary Neville mentioned about the FA Cup. Why has the FA Cup lost its buzz? Because every kid's dream when we were kids was to play in the FA Cup final. You didn't speak about winning the league. You spoke about winning the FA Cup final. And then Gary Neville said that to get to the FA Cup final, the club gets £1.7 million or something. To get one place in the Premier League, it's £3.1 million. So that's why they're resting players to get ready for a Saturday, because it's worth more money to go one place up in the Premier League than it is to win it. I mean, come on. What's that about?”Clough famously never got his hands on the FA Cup, suffering defeat to Tottenham in the 1991 final. Mourinho did capture that prize during his first stint at Chelsea, with modern coaches seeking to emulate the achievements of larger-than-life characters that went before them.Nottingham Forest's front of shirt partner Bally Bet is on a mission to give long-serving grassroots players the recognition they have earned. Forest great Mark Crossley has been set the challenge of compiling the first ever All-Stars Vets squad, made up from the real characters of the game in a celebration of everything that makes grassroots great. Crossley will be ably supported by other recognisable Forest faces as he goes about assembling the Bally Bet All-Stars.The All-Stars will then be given the full Premier League treatment, swapping the recreation grounds for the City Ground, as they turn out against a team of hand-picked Forest legends towards the end of May. Think you’ve got what it takes? If you’re 30+ and ready to take on the legends, submit your interest now by following this link and be part of it.

1

The Legacy of Brian Clough

In the 1970s and 80s, Brian Clough made waves in English football by transforming Nottingham Forest into European champions. Alongside Peter Taylor, Clough's unapologetic and charismatic approach solidified his status as a managerial icon.

2

Jose Mourinho: The Modern Disrupter

Jose Mourinho's reign as a mercurial tactician saw him clinch Champions League titles and domestic glory across Europe. His confrontational style and tactical acumen have drawn comparisons to Clough, setting the stage for an epic clash had the two managers met.

3

Insider Insights from Mark Crossley

Former Nottingham Forest goalkeeper Mark Crossley provides intriguing perspectives on the potential showdown between Clough and Mourinho. His belief that Clough would emerge victorious highlights the enduring impact of the 'Miracle Men' era.

4

Managerial Evolution and Challenges

Crossley delves into the changing landscape of football management, pointing out the shift from traditional managers to head coaches under increased scrutiny and pressure. The evolution of the game has placed a heavier focus on results and player dynamics, altering the dynamics of club management.

5

Grassroots Initiative with Bally Bet All-Stars

The partnership with Bally Bet to honor grassroots players and recognize their contributions is a refreshing initiative. The All-Stars Vets squad project curated by Crossley embodies the spirit of grassroots football, offering ordinary players a chance to shine on a legendary stage.

Published on Mar 19, 2026