2 min read
Football Insider

Alan Shearer's Controversy Over Anthony Gordon: A Continuing Saga

The ongoing controversy between legendary former Newcastle United striker Alan Shearer and England winger Anthony Gordon continues to captivate the football world. Shearer has reaffirmed his stance regarding Gordon's absence from the starting XI against Barcelona, leading to a public exchange of words between the two. Let's delve into the drama that has unfolded and the reactions it has sparked.

Alan Shearer's Controversy Over Anthony Gordon: A Continuing Saga

Legendary former Newcastle United striker Alan Shearer has doubled down on his comments regarding Anthony Gordon's absence from the starting XI against Barcelona. After Gordon strongly denied suggestions he was unwilling to play, labelling the claims as "nonsense", Shearer has publicly stood by his initial criticism of the winger.The drama was sparked when Gordon was benched for the first leg against the Catalan giants, leading Shearer to previously suggest that it would take "something extraordinary" to keep him out of such a fixture, amid suggestions illness had got the better of the Newcastle forward. This prompted a furious response from Gordon following his match-winning performance against Chelsea at Stamford Bridge.“Usually I don't like to clear stuff up because I don't care too much,” Gordon told the media. “But this one does need clearing up because it was just nonsense. Saying I didn't want to play in the biggest game of my career is absolute nonsense."The veteran pundit and Newcastle icon has made it clear he has no regrets after questioning Gordon’s absence from the starting line-up during the Magpies' massive Champions League clash against Barcelona. Speaking on The Rest Is Football podcast, Shearer responded to the winger's recent comments by saying: “Good! I love it! That’s fine. You always get the chance, the right to reply as a player. I wouldn’t change anything I said the other night against Barcelona. Illness wouldn’t have kept me out for a game, I know he said it was the manager’s [decision].”Shearer was not the only one to question Gordon’s professionalism, with former Manchester United duo Roy Keane and Wayne Rooney also weighing in on the situation. Keane echoed the sentiment on The Overlap, stating: "How can you be ill but come on for half an hour?" Rooney, too, was dismissive of the illness claims, saying: "If you're ill, you're ill. You shouldn't be there. He walked past us before the game and wouldn't shake our hands. He said he didn't want us to catch anything, but then he's going into the dressing room with his team-mates."This allegation of failing to acknowledge the media team properly was vehemently denied by the former Everton man, who detailed his isolation in a makeshift space to avoid spreading the illness."I think it was Rooney that said I walked past and didn't shake their hands, but then went in the changing room," Gordon added. "I got changed by myself in a changing room the size of this. It was just me and a sink. So it was complete nonsense, and I think they need to do better at what they are doing."Add GOAL.com as a preferred source on Google to see more of our reportingNewcastle will now turn their attention to the second leg of their Champions League tie against Barcelona on Wednesday night. The two sides played out a 1-1 draw in the first leg at St. James' Park, leaving the fixture finely balanced ahead of the trip to Spain. Gordon's availability in the starting XI will be a major focal point in the build-up. The winger has been a crucial figure for Eddie Howe's side in Europe this season and currently sits second in the Champions League scoring charts with 10 goals, trailing only Real Madrid's Kylian Mbappe (13).

1

Shearer Stands Firm

Despite vehement denials from Gordon, Shearer remains resolute in his criticism of the winger's absence on a crucial European night. The former striker, known for his no-nonsense approach, has doubled down on his initial comments, indicating a belief that illness should not have kept Gordon out of contention for such a significant fixture.

2

Public Dispute Escalates

Gordon's strong rebuttal to Shearer's claims has further escalated the public dispute. The winger's denial of any reluctance to play and his assertion that the illness claims were baseless has added fuel to the already fiery conversation surrounding his absence from the starting line-up against Barcelona.

3

Punditry Backlash

Shearer isn't the only pundit to question Gordon's professionalism, with Roy Keane and Wayne Rooney also weighing in on the situation. The former Manchester United duo expressed skepticism over Gordon's reported illness and actions on matchday, leading to a broader discussion within the footballing community.

4

Clarification and Counterclaims

Gordon has sought to clarify the circumstances surrounding his absence, refuting allegations of unprofessional behavior. The winger detailed his isolation measures to prevent the spread of illness and dismissed claims made by Rooney regarding his interactions with the opposing team.

5

The Road Ahead for Newcastle

As Newcastle prepare for the crucial second leg against Barcelona, the spotlight remains on Gordon's potential inclusion in the starting XI. With his impressive form in the Champions League this season, the winger's availability will be a key talking point leading up to the decisive fixture.

Published on Mar 16, 2026