1 min read
Football Insider

The Dilemma of Phil Foden: A Charitable Sub or Strategic Move by Guardiola?

Manchester United legend Wayne Rooney expresses concern over Phil Foden's limited playing time in the Carabao Cup final, raising questions about his future under Pep Guardiola's management. Foden's decline in minutes and form have sparked debate within the football community.

The Dilemma of Phil Foden: A Charitable Sub or Strategic Move by Guardiola?

Manchester United legend Wayne Rooney has said he feels "sad" for Phil Foden after the Manchester City star was reduced to a late cameo in the Carabao Cup final. The England international, once among the first names on Pep Guardiola's team sheet, was forced to watch from the sidelines as his side secured more silverware at Wembley.The 25-year-old’s decline in minutes has been one of the more shocking storylines of City's season. Having been named the PFA Players’ Player of the Year in 2023/24, Foden has struggled to maintain his place following the arrivals of Rayan Cherki and Antoine Semenyo. In fact, he replaced Cherki in the 90th minute at Wembley, highlighting how far he has fallen down the pecking order."I felt sad for him but not sad because he is coming on in a cup final," Rooney said on the BBC's Wayne Rooney Show. "There was a game a few days ago when he didn't even get on the pitch. If that was Max Dowman coming on at the end, you would think good experience. But to see Phil Foden coming on in a cup final, it felt like a charity sub to get him on the pitch.”Foden has managed just four starts in City’s last 13 matches across all competitions and hasn't found the back of the net in 20, a run that stretches back to mid-December. Rooney added: "I don't know what has happened, he is a top player. It feels strange he can't get anywhere near the team. It feels like something has gone on there. I thought Foden was in good form but all of a sudden we haven't seen him get any minutes."Despite the frustration of his limited role, Foden remained professional while celebrating City's latest trophy. The midfielder acknowledged that his form hasn't been at its peak but expressed a desire to reclaim his spot in Guardiola's starting XI for the business end of the campaign.Addressing his current situation after the final whistle, Foden spoke on the “ups and downs” a footballer can go through."It’s just about how you pick yourself back up," he said. "I’m still keeping my head down, trying to train as well as I can every day and hopefully I come back after the internationals a lot sharper and hopefully I can get more minutes and be back to where I was at the start of the season."While Foden has been included in Thomas Tuchel’s 35-man provisional England squad for the March internationals, his lack of domestic playing time is a major concern. Rooney believes the current situation will be weighing heavily on the midfielder's mind as the summer tournament approaches."Firstly he will be pleased they won the cup but from a selfish point of view, he would have wanted to be out there and having an influence," Rooney said. "That will be a tough one for him." Add GOAL.com as a preferred source on Google to see more of our reportingFoden will hope to impress Three Lions boss Tuchel in the upcoming clashes against Uruguay and Japan. The 25-year-old came off the bench when England finished off their World Cup qualifying campaign against Serbia and Albania in November.

1

Rooney's Take on Foden's Situation

In a recent episode of the Wayne Rooney Show on the BBC, Wayne Rooney voiced his disappointment over Phil Foden's reduced role at Manchester City. The former United captain described Foden's late cameo in the Carabao Cup final as 'sad' and 'like a charity sub,' insinuating that the young talent deserves more opportunities to showcase his abilities.

2

Foden's Struggles and Professionalism

Despite facing limited playing time and a lack of form, Phil Foden has maintained his professionalism and commitment to reclaiming his spot in the starting lineup. The English midfielder acknowledged the challenges footballers face in experiencing highs and lows, expressing his determination to improve and contribute more to the team.

3

Looking Ahead to International Duty

As Foden prepares for upcoming internationals with England, his lack of domestic playing time presents a significant concern. With Thomas Tuchel including him in the provisional squad, Foden aims to impress on the international stage and prove his readiness for a more prominent role in both club and country competitions.

Published on Mar 23, 2026